Brian Vitko opens the show. He then calls out both Psycho Circus Match team captains, to settle which team gets the advantage into the Psycho Circus Match

Larry Legend returns to the Psycho Circus

Joker's Wild Battle Royal

Jabali Jr. Wins the Battle Royal

Grim Reefer def. Alvin Alvarez

J-Ro def. Kriss Stark

Triple Threat Tag Team Match

Rack & Sack def. Apollyon and Bill Carr, and Milk Chocolate - New #1 Contender's for the NYWC Tag Team Championship

Anthony Nese def. “Kentucky Gentleman” Chuck Taylor

Master of the Mat Match

Drew Gulak def. Alex Reynolds, Papadon, and #1 John Silver

12th Annual Psycho Circus Match

Starlet Championship: NYWC Starlet Champion Marti Belle def. Chrissy Rivera/NYWC Championship: Mike Mondo def. King Mega - New NYWC Champion/NYWC Tag Team Championship: NYWC Tag Team Champions Athletic Inc. def. Mikey Whipwreck and Stockade/NYWC FUSION Championship: "Flawless" Blake Morris def. Francis Kipland Stevens - New NYWC FUSION Champion/Rex Lawless def. DJ Hyde